Collagen drinks and VAT: Bottled Science changes the legal landscape as another appeal moves forward

13min read

Please sign up to receive insights, publications and updates from our experts.

A recent Upper Tribunal decision could have significant implications for the VAT treatment of collagen drinks, liquid food supplements and other borderline products. A separate decision allowing the Absolute Collagen appeal to proceed also means further guidance may follow. Mark Ellis, Partner and VAT specialist, explains what has changed and what manufacturers, wholesalers and retailers should consider.

The VAT treatment of collagen drinks has become considerably more interesting. In our recent article on the Minerva Research Labs decision, we explained how the First-tier Tribunal (‘FtT’) concluded that a range of collagen drinks was standard-rated rather than zero-rated as food. The Tribunal placed significant weight on how those products were marketed, presented and used by customers.

Since then, two further developments have underlined how unsettled this area remains. First, the Upper Tribunal (‘UT’) has released its decision in Bottled Science Limited v HMRC [2026] UKUT 00429 (TCC). That decision introduces an important new question into the analysis: is the product a “drink”? That may sound obvious, but for VAT purposes it could be crucial.

Second, in Laceby Limited v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 01541 (TC), the FtT has lifted the stay on an appeal concerning Absolute Collagen for Women and Absolute Collagen for Men. The substantive question of whether those products qualify for zero-rating has not yet been decided, but the appeal can now proceed without waiting for the separate Healthspan litigation.

Together, the cases show that businesses should not assume that Minerva provides the final answer for all collagen drinks.

Why does being a “drink” matter?

UK VAT legislation zero-rates “food of a kind used for human consumption”. Importantly, Note 1 to Group 1 of Schedule 8 to the Value Added Tax Act 1994 states that “Food includes drink.” Until recently, businesses and HMRC generally approached borderline products by asking whether, looking at all their characteristics, they were properly described as “food”.

The UT has now held that this is not necessarily the correct starting point for a liquid product. Following the Court of Appeal’s decision in Innovative Bites, the UT concluded that the words “Food includes drink” are conclusive. If a product is properly classified as a drink of a kind used for human consumption, it is therefore also food, unless treating it as food would clearly make no sense.  That does not, however, automatically mean that the product is zero-rated. This is because some types of food and drink are specifically excluded from zero-rating. Most importantly for liquid products, “other beverages” are generally standard-rated.

The distinction between a “drink” and a “beverage” could become extremely important for manufacturers of collagen products, liquid supplements and other consumable liquids.

What happened in Bottled Science?

Bottled Science sells Skinade, a liquid collagen product. It claimed repayment of approximately £1.25 million of VAT that it had previously accounted for, arguing that Skinade should have been zero-rated as food. HMRC disagreed.

The FtT had considered Skinade’s formulation, nutritional value, ingredients, taste, production, packaging, marketing and purpose. Although several factors were essentially neutral, its packaging and marketing weighed heavily against treating it as food.

Skinade was marketed as an anti-ageing skincare product, was associated with the beauty and aesthetics industry and was presented quite differently from conventional food products. The Tribunal ultimately decided that Skinade was not food and was therefore standard-rated.  That analysis closely resembles the approach subsequently adopted by the FtT in Minerva. But Bottled Science appealed.

The UT’s decision

The UT allowed Bottled Science’s appeal on one important ground. The FtT originally said: “The legislation tells us that food includes drink, but it does not follow from Skinade being a drink that it is automatically a food.” The UT has now held that this was wrong as a matter of law.

Applying the Court of Appeal’s reasoning in Innovative Bites, the UT decided that if Skinade is properly classified as a drink, the legislation means that it is also food. It is not then necessary to conduct a second assessment of whether it has enough of the characteristics we ordinarily associate with food.

The problem was that the FtT had never actually decided whether Skinade was a “drink”. That particular question had not been argued before it. The UT therefore could not simply conclude that Skinade was zero-rated. Instead, it set aside the original decision and sent the case back to a differently constituted FtT to decide whether Skinade is a drink of a kind used for human consumption.

Surely a collagen drink is a “drink”?

Not necessarily, at least for VAT purposes. Bottled Science argued for a straightforward approach based broadly on the ordinary dictionary meaning of a drink. The UT rejected that approach. Instead, the newly constituted FtT will have to look at all the relevant characteristics of Skinade and make what lawyers call a multi-factorial assessment of whether it is properly described as a drink.

This is potentially important for a much wider range of products. A liquid does not automatically become a “drink” simply because someone swallows it. The UT gave liquid medicines as an obvious example. The boundary between a “drink” and another consumable liquid therefore remains to be developed.

And what about “beverages”?

This could ultimately prove to be the most important part of the dispute. HMRC had previously accepted that Skinade was not a “beverage”. But because Bottled Science is now allowed to pursue the different argument that Skinade is a “drink”, the UT decided that HMRC must also be allowed to reconsider whether Skinade is an “other beverage”.

That matters because most “other beverages”, including fruit juices and bottled waters, are specifically excluded from zero-rating and are therefore standard-rated. There could consequently be a somewhat unusual result: Skinade could succeed in establishing that it is a “drink”, which makes it “food”, only for HMRC then to establish that it is also a “beverage”, taking it back out of the zero rate of VAT. The next FtT will therefore need to navigate the distinction between those concepts.

What is the Absolute Collagen appeal about?

Laceby Limited sells Absolute Collagen for Women and Absolute Collagen for Men. It asked HMRC to confirm that the products were “food of a kind used for human consumption” and therefore zero-rated. The products were described as containing marine collagen, water, fruit flavourings, vitamin C, sweetener and natural lemon juice. Laceby Limited argues that a multi-factorial analysis of their ingredients, nutritional content, method of consumption and marketing supports zero-rating. It also relies on HMRC’s treatment of powdered collagen products as food.

HMRC decided that the products were standard-rated because they were held out for sale as beauty or health supplements rather than food. HMRC maintains that consumers buy them to obtain cosmetic or beauty-related benefits, rather than nutrients needed to nourish the body, and that the products are not beverages.

  • the correct legal test for identifying “food of a kind used for human consumption”;
  • the weight to be given to marketing and how the products are held out for sale;
  • whether the products possess the essential characteristics of liquid food;
  • the relevance of their ingredients and nutritional content;
  • whether refusing zero-rating would breach fiscal neutrality; and
  • the VAT classification of the raw collagen used to produce the products.

These arguments have not yet been determined. The latest Laceby Limited FtT decision concerns only whether the appeal should remain stayed.

Does this overturn the Minerva FtT decision?

No, but the combined developments make the position considerably less settled. The Minerva decision concerns different products and evidence. Its analysis of marketing, packaging, nutritional characteristics and customer use remains highly relevant.

Importantly, the UT in Bottled Science also rejected the company’s other two grounds of appeal. It found that the original FtT had been entitled to give substantial weight to Skinade’s packaging and marketing, and that the purpose for which customers consumed the product was a legitimate factor to consider. Indeed, the UT described the original FtT’s analysis as “exemplary”.

The earlier lesson has therefore not disappeared. Marketing and product positioning can still be extremely important. What has changed is the legal question to which the evidence may have to be applied. For a liquid product, the first question may now be whether the product is a drink, rather than simply whether it looks sufficiently like conventional food. The Laceby Limited litigation may provide further guidance on that broader classification exercise, but its eventual outcome will depend on the evidence concerning the particular Absolute Collagen products.

What does this mean for manufacturers?

Businesses selling collagen drinks, liquid supplements and similar products should consider revisiting their VAT analysis.

Is the product a drink?

Consider how the product is consumed, described, sold and actually used by customers. Simply being liquid and swallowed will not settle the question.

If it is a drink, could it also be a beverage?

This could determine whether a product which initially falls within zero-rated food is nevertheless brought back within the standard rate. Evidence concerning why and how customers consume the product may become particularly important.

What does the marketing say about the product?

Marketing remains highly relevant. The UT expressly rejected the argument that the previous Tribunal had given excessive weight to Skinade’s marketing. It confirmed that, depending on the facts, the way a product is marketed and sold can carry great or even dominant weight in a VAT classification exercise. Businesses should therefore continue to review packaging, websites, advertising, social-media content, retail positioning, customer reviews and terminology such as “dose”, “treatment”, “beauty regime” and “clinically formulated”.

What should businesses do now?

For businesses producing or selling liquid nutritional, health, wellness or beauty products, we recommend reviewing existing VAT classifications rather than waiting for the Skinade litigation to conclude. That review should capture:

  • ingredients and nutritional content;
  • the physical form and method of consumption;
  • how the product is described;
  • packaging and instructions for use;
  • website and advertising materials;
  • sales channels and retail placement;
  • customer research and evidence of actual use;
  • whether the product could properly be characterised as a “drink”;
  • whether it could also be a “beverage”; and
  • the reasons supporting the VAT position adopted.

That evidence should be retained in a contemporaneous VAT classification file.

Businesses that have historically accounted for VAT at 20% on products which may arguably be zero-rated should also consider whether the latest decision justifies protecting a potential repayment position, taking account of the applicable time limits and the fact that the law remains unsettled. Equally, businesses already zero-rating borderline products should not assume that Bottled Science validates that treatment. The “beverage” exclusion, together with marketing and actual customer use, may still point towards standard-rating.

The Laceby Limited decision recognises the commercial uncertainty that can arise while a business is waiting for the VAT treatment of its products to be resolved. The FtT accepted that uncertainty could affect margins, competitiveness, profitability and commercial planning.  That makes product classification an issue for product development, marketing and senior management, as well as the tax function.

The key takeaway

The VAT treatment of collagen drinks is in doubt. Minerva showed that nutritional content and food regulation are not enough on their own to secure zero-rating and that marketing and customer use can be highly influential.  Bottled Science now adds something important: if a liquid product is properly a “drink”, the legislation conclusively treats it as “food”. The question may then move to whether it is an excluded “beverage”.  That apparently small distinction could have significant consequences for the VAT treatment of collagen drinks, liquid supplements and other innovative products that do not fit neatly into traditional food categories.

Laceby Limited adds a further dimension. Its Absolute Collagen appeal can now proceed independently and will examine arguments concerning the correct classification test, nutritional characteristics, marketing, essential characteristics and fiscal neutrality.

For businesses in this market, the message is not that collagen drinks are now zero-rated. It is that the legal analysis is developing, the outcome remains product-specific, and existing VAT treatments may merit another look.

FAQs

Are collagen drinks now zero-rated for VAT?

No. The UT has not decided that Skinade, or collagen drinks generally, are zero-rated. It has decided that if Skinade is a “drink”, it is also “food”. A new FtT must decide whether Skinade is actually a “drink” and, potentially, whether it is also an excluded standard-rated “beverage”.

Has the Tribunal decided that Absolute Collagen is zero-rated?

No. The latest Laceby Limited decision only lifts the stay on the appeal. The FtT has not yet determined whether Absolute Collagen for Women or Absolute Collagen for Men is food, a drink, a beverage or otherwise entitled to zero-rating.

Why is the Laceby decision relevant?

It means that another substantive appeal concerning liquid collagen products can now move forward. It also illustrates the commercial problems caused by prolonged uncertainty, including possible effects on pricing, margins, competitiveness and evidence preservation.

Does marketing still matter?

Yes. The UT confirmed that marketing, packaging, customer use and the purpose for which a product is consumed can remain important and, in an appropriate case, marketing can carry great or even dominant weight.

What should businesses with similar products do?

Businesses should review the VAT classification of borderline liquid products against the new drink analysis, while also considering whether the product could be an excluded beverage. They should document the evidence supporting their treatment and consider whether any historic repayment position needs to be protected before relevant accounting periods fall outside the applicable time limits.

Will the next Skinade decision settle the issue for other collagen drinks?

Not necessarily. VAT classification remains highly fact-specific. Different formulations, marketing, packaging, sales channels and patterns of customer use may produce different outcomes.

Should businesses change their VAT treatment now?

Not automatically. A change should be based on the facts of the particular product and a properly documented analysis. However, the Bottled Science UT decision and the progression of the Absolute Collagen appeal are sufficiently important that businesses with materially similar products should review their existing position now.

How can we help

The recent Upper Tribunal decision on collagen drinks could have wider implications for the VAT treatment of food supplements and similar products. Our VAT specialists can help you assess the potential impact on your business.

Contact our experts